Playing games with magic or gods isn’t automatically haram if you avoid harmful mechanics and time-wasting. The real issues are: (1) Gambling mechanics (like gacha), (2) Neglecting prayers and duties, (3) Games designed for addiction, (4) Worshipping fictional gods as real. If a game has these, skip it. If not, you’re fine with moderation.

---

What This Really Means (Simple Explanation)

Look, I used to think all games with magic were forbidden. Then I researched actual Islamic scholars from Darul Uloom Deoband (one of Islam’s most respected institutions), and found something interesting: Islam doesn’t forbid the game itself—it forbids specific harmful actions inside the game.​

Here’s the difference:

• Reading fantasy books (like Lord of the Rings) = Usually okay​
• Playing games where you MUST worship a god to progress = Not okay​
• Playing games with magic as decoration = Depends on other factors​
• Spending real money on random loot boxes = Looks like gambling​
• Gaming for 12 hours and missing prayers = Definitely haram​​

The scholars agree on one thing: It’s not about the magic or gods in the game. It’s about what the game makes you do, what it costs you, and how much time it steals from your real life.​

---

Why Understanding This Matters (Benefits + Importance)

Here’s what happens when you get this wrong:

I’ve seen three types of Muslims. First type: plays any game without thinking—misses prayers, fails school, spends rent money on gacha mechanics. Second type: refuses to play ANY game ever because someone said “all games are haram”—misses healthy entertainment and social connection. Third type: understands the actual rules and makes smart choices.​

You need to understand this because:

1. Your time is currency. Islam says time is more valuable than gold. Gaming 12 hours a day isn’t entertainment—it’s stealing from your own future.​
2. Gambling hidden in games is real. Genshin Impact has gacha mechanics (spend money, get random rewards). Islamic scholars in Malaysia officially called this haram because it resembles gambling.​
3. You don’t want to regret later. I’ve read posts from Muslims who spent $3,000+ on gacha games, then felt guilty. Understanding the rules first prevents this.
4. “Harmless fun” can become addiction. Games are designed by psychologists to hook you. Islam warns against anything that distracts you from Allah and your duties.​
5. You can actually enjoy games guilt-free. Once you know what’s actually forbidden, you play without that nagging “Is this haram?” voice.

---

The 3 Key Criteria That Determine If a Game Is Okay (Step-by-Step Breakdown)

Step 1: Check If the Game Involves Gambling Mechanics

What counts as gambling in games?

Gacha systems = You spend real money, game randomizes what you get back. This is maysir (gambling).​

Loot boxes = Same thing. Pay money, get random reward. Multiple Islamic scholars ruled this haram.​

Free-to-play (F2P) gacha? = Different story. If you never spend real money, most scholars say it’s fine as long as you don’t waste time.​

Real-world example: Genshin Impact lets you play completely free, but spending $100 might give you 0 good characters or 5. That’s gambling.​

Pro Tip: Before playing any game, search “[game name] + free to play” to see if you can experience the full game without money. If you can’t progress without spending, that’s a red flag.

Step 2: Check If You’ll Neglect Your Real Life

This is where most Muslims mess up. You can play a game with gods and magic IF—and only if—it doesn’t interfere with:

• Your 5 daily prayers (non-negotiable)​​
• Your work/school responsibilities​
• Your family duties​
• Your physical health (sleep, eating, exercise)​

The Islamic rule: Entertainment is okay. But the moment it becomes an obstacle to your main duties, it becomes haram.​​

Real talk: If you’re missing Fajr prayer because of gaming, stop. If you’re failing classes because of gaming, stop. If you’re lying to your parents about homework to play games, stop.

Scholar Mufti Muhammad Shafi’s rule: A game is permissible IF it has a beneficial purpose (like stress relief) AND it doesn’t make you neglect Allah or your responsibilities. But if you’re gaming just to waste time with zero benefit, that’s the Islamic equivalent of flushing money down the toilet.​

Step 3: Check the Game’s Content

This is where Genshin Impact and God of War actually differ.

Genshin Impact:​​

• Has fictional gods (Archons)
• Players can “worship” statues for healing items
• Contains light magic/mystical elements
• No explicit forcing of actual worship

God of War:​

• Portrays the Christian God as weak, deceiving, and flawed
• Main character kills “gods”
• More philosophically anti-religious
• Not just depicting false gods—depicting disrespect toward the Divine

The key question: Does the game force you to perform worship acts, or are gods just part of the setting?

According to Darul Uloom Deoband scholars:​

• Must-do worship actions (forced to pray to a statue to progress) = Don’t play​
• Optional worship mechanics (you can heal without praying to anything) = You can play if other factors are okay​
• Magic as world-building (not real magic, just a story element) = Usually fine​

---

What Scholars Actually Say (Expert Guidance from Deoband & Others)

Let me break down the real fatwa (Islamic ruling) for you.

From Darul Uloom Deoband (the primary source for Islamic law in South Asia):​

“Entertainment which has no purpose behind it and does not have a beneficial goal is haram or strongly disliked. But entertainment that contains a benefit (like mental relaxation), if its prohibition is not explicitly mentioned in the Quran/Hadith, then it depends on two things: (1) Does it distract you from Allah’s remembrance and prayers? (2) Does experience show its harm is greater than its benefit?”​

Translation: A game is only forbidden if it either:

1. Explicitly does something the Quran forbids (like gambling)
2. OR makes you neglect prayers and duties
3. OR is designed to be addictive and harmful

From the official Deoband website on gaming:​

The scholars give 5 categories of entertainment:

Category	Type	Ruling
1	Time-wasting with zero benefit	Strongly Haram
2	Has some benefit but forbidden in Quran/Hadith (like gambling)	Haram
3	Addictive and harms your duties	Haram/Strongly Disliked
4	Has benefit but you play with wrong intention (pure amusement)	Disliked
5	Has benefit AND played with right intention AND doesn’t interfere with duties	Permissible

Where do Genshin and God of War fall?

• Genshin (free, no time-wasting, no mandatory worship): Category 4-5 (Disliked to Permissible)​
• God of War (violent, anti-religious messaging): Category 2-3 (Haram)​
• Any game where you gamble real money: Category 2 (Haram)​

---

Expert Tips & Best Practices

Tip 1: The 30-Minute Rule (Reality-Based, Not Extreme)

Don’t let anyone tell you gaming is totally haram. And don’t let anyone say you can game 12 hours a day. The middle path = 30-60 minutes per day maximum, only after ALL obligations are done.​

This means:

• Prayers first ✓
• Work/school/family ✓
• Basic health (exercise, eating right) ✓
• Quality time with people ✓
• Then gaming ✓

Tip 2: Never Spend Real Money on Randomized Rewards

This is the easiest rule. Don’t spend $1 on gacha mechanics. Play for free or don’t play.​

Genshin Impact officially has this problem. If you’re tempted to spend money because the game is designed to make you want to, uninstall it. It’s not worth it.​

Tip 3: The “Intention Test”

Before playing, ask yourself:

• Am I playing to relax for 30 minutes? ✓ (Good intention)
• Am I playing to avoid my homework? ✗ (Bad intention)
• Am I playing to improve my social life (gaming with friends)? ✓ (Good intention)
• Am I playing because I’m addicted and can’t stop? ✗ (Bad intention)

Islamic scholars say the same action can be haram or halal depending on your intention. So be honest with yourself.​

Tip 4: Know When to Quit

If your game:

• Makes you miss prayers
• Costs you money you can’t afford
• Makes you lie to your family
• Causes you to fail school
• Has obvious shirk mechanics (forced worship)
• Has explicit sexual content

Delete it immediately. No game is worth compromising your faith.

Read more: Is Music Haram? The Honest Truth, 5 Scholarly Views & How to Quit Addiction​

---

Common Mistakes to Avoid

Mistake 1: “It’s Just Fiction, So It’s Fine”

No. Context matters. Reading a book about Greek mythology ≠ Playing a game where YOU perform worship actions.​

With books, you’re an observer. With games, you’re the actor. Games are more immersive and psychologically powerful.​

Mistake 2: “I Don’t Believe in These Gods, So It Doesn’t Matter”

Wrong. The Quran warns against even appearing to mock or participate in shirk, regardless of your internal belief.​

Example from Quran (9:65-66): Some people said “we were just joking” about disbelieving. Allah said that doesn’t excuse them.​

The principle: Don’t voluntarily put yourself in situations where you’re performing forbidden actions, even as play.​

Mistake 3: “One Game Won’t Hurt, I’m Disciplined”

False confidence kills more people than actual weakness. Games are designed by psychologists to be addictive.​

You think you’ll play 30 minutes? You’ll play 3 hours. You think you won’t spend money? You’ll spend $50. You think you’ll quit anytime? Try quitting.

Real talk: Addiction doesn’t announce itself. It creeps up.​

Mistake 4: “All Games Are Haram Anyway”

This is also wrong. Many games are completely fine:

• Strategy games (chess is actually debated but mostly allowed)​
• Sports games
• Puzzle games
• Educational games
• Cooperative games with no haram content

The rule isn’t “games are haram.” The rule is “some games, under some conditions, become problematic.”​

---

Real Examples Explained Simply

Example 1: Genshin Impact

What players do: Explore a fantasy world, fight enemies, level up characters. Some characters are depicted as “Archons” (gods). To heal, you can worship statues.

Is it haram?

• If you spend real money on gacha: YES, haram. This is gambling.​
• If you play free for hours daily: Probably haram (time-wasting, neglecting duties)​
• If you play free for 30 minutes daily after all duties: Debatable, but probably okay.​
• If you roleplay actual worship of these gods in real life: YES, absolutely haram (shirk)​

The honest answer: Most Muslims playing Genshin are either spending money (haram) or wasting excessive time (haram). But it COULD be okay with serious discipline.​

Example 2: God of War

What players do: Kill Greek gods, see the Christian God depicted as evil and weak.

Is it haram?

• The scholars’ consensus: Yes, haram. Not because of fantasy, but because the game specifically portrays divinity as weak and contemptible.​

A scholar explained: “The game depicts God as deceiving, cunning, helpless, prone to error—attributes that contradict Islamic belief. Indulging in this can harm your spiritual beliefs.”​

Why it’s worse than Genshin: You’re not just playing in a world with gods. You’re being told by the game designers that gods are evil and weak. That messaging is dangerous to faith.​

Example 3: A Game That’s Actually Fine

Imagine a game where:

• You explore a fantasy world (no worship mechanics)
• Magic is just aesthetics (like different colored attacks)
• No gods depicted
• No gambling
• You can beat it in 20 hours total
• You play 30 minutes weekly

Is it haram? No. This is entertainment within Islamic boundaries.​

Examples that fit this: Many indie games, some RPGs without shirk elements, strategy games, etc.

---

FAQ: Questions Scholars Get Asked (Answered Clearly)

---

What You Should Actually Do (Final Conclusion)

Here’s the honest bottom line:

If you want to play Genshin Impact or God of War:

God of War? Don’t play it. The game explicitly disrespects the concept of God. That’s not about fantasy—that’s about the game’s message.​

Genshin Impact? You CAN play it IF:

1. You never spend real money (zero exceptions)​
2. You limit yourself to 30 minutes daily, only after all duties​
3. You mute any voices/music that bother you​
4. You admit to yourself that you’re playing a time-waster, not doing something important
5. You’re genuinely okay skipping it for a week if needed (not addicted)​

Better alternatives? Find games with zero haram content. Hundreds exist.​